india-map

FIND YOUR MP

Switch to Hindi (हिंदी)
  • MPs & MLAs
    Parliament States 2024 Elections
  • Legislatures
    Parliament
    Session Track Parliament Diary Parliament Committees Primer Vital Stats
    States
    Legislature Track Vital Stats
    Discussion Papers
  • Bills & Acts
    Bills Parliament Acts Parliament Bills States State Legislative Briefs Acts States
  • Budgets
    Parliament States Discussion Papers
  • Policy
    Discussion Papers Science & Technology Policy Monthly Policy Reviews Annual Policy Reviews Committee Reports President Address Vital Stats COVID-19
  • LAMP
    About the LAMP Fellowship How to Apply Life at LAMP Videos Meet our Fellows Get in touch
  • Careers

FIND YOUR MP

Parliament States 2024 Elections
Session Track Parliament Diary Parliament Committees Primer Vital Stats
Legislature Track Vital Stats
Discussion Papers
Bills Parliament Acts Parliament Bills States State Legislative briefs Acts States
Parliament States Discussion Papers
Discussion Papers Science & Technology Policy Monthly Policy Reviews Annual Policy Reviews Committee Reports President Address Vital Stats COVID-19
About the LAMP Fellowship How to Apply Life at LAMP Videos Meet our Fellows Get in touch
  • Articles by PRS Team
  • monsoon-session-india’s-parliamentary-democracy-is-in-crisis

Archives

2025
  • May, 2025
  • April, 2025
  • February, 2025
  • January, 2025
2024
  • August, 2024
  • July, 2024
  • June, 2024
  • May, 2024
  • April, 2024
  • March, 2024
  • February, 2024
2023
  • December, 2023
  • November, 2023
  • October, 2023
  • September, 2023
  • August, 2023
  • July, 2023
  • June, 2023
  • May, 2023
  • April, 2023
  • March, 2023
  • February, 2023
  • January, 2023
2022
  • December, 2022
  • November, 2022
  • October, 2022
  • September, 2022
  • August, 2022
  • July, 2022
  • June, 2022
  • May, 2022
  • April, 2022
  • March, 2022
  • February, 2022
  • January, 2022
2021
  • December, 2021
  • November, 2021
  • October, 2021
  • September, 2021
  • August, 2021
  • July, 2021
  • June, 2021
  • May, 2021
  • April, 2021
  • March, 2021
  • February, 2021
  • January, 2021
2020
  • December, 2020
  • October, 2020
  • September, 2020
  • August, 2020
  • July, 2020
  • June, 2020
  • May, 2020
  • April, 2020
  • March, 2020
  • January, 2020
2019
  • December, 2019
  • November, 2019
  • October, 2019
  • September, 2019
  • August, 2019
  • July, 2019
  • June, 2019
  • May, 2019
  • February, 2019
  • January, 2019
2018
  • December, 2018
  • October, 2018
  • September, 2018
  • August, 2018
  • July, 2018
  • May, 2018
  • April, 2018
  • January, 2018
2017
  • December, 2017
  • May, 2017
  • March, 2017
  • February, 2017
  • January, 2017
2016
  • December, 2016
  • August, 2016
  • March, 2016
2015
  • April, 2015
  • February, 2015
2014
  • December, 2014
  • November, 2014
  • August, 2014
  • June, 2014
  • May, 2014
  • April, 2014
  • March, 2014
  • February, 2014
  • January, 2014
2013
  • December, 2013
  • November, 2013
  • October, 2013
  • September, 2013
  • August, 2013
  • July, 2013
  • June, 2013
  • May, 2013
  • April, 2013
  • March, 2013
  • February, 2013
2012
  • December, 2012
  • November, 2012
  • August, 2012
  • May, 2012
  • April, 2012
  • March, 2012
  • February, 2012
  • January, 2012
2011
  • December, 2011
  • November, 2011
  • September, 2011
  • August, 2011
  • July, 2011
  • June, 2011
  • May, 2011
  • April, 2011
  • March, 2011
  • February, 2011
  • January, 2011
2010
  • December, 2010
  • November, 2010
  • October, 2010
  • September, 2010
  • August, 2010
  • July, 2010
  • June, 2010
  • May, 2010
  • April, 2010
  • March, 2010
  • February, 2010
  • January, 2010
2009
  • December, 2009
  • November, 2009
  • October, 2009
  • April, 2009

Monsoon session: India’s parliamentary democracy is in crisis


Chakshu Roy, Hindustan Times, August 12, 2021, ,

Parliament can change its rules to give MPs more teeth in questioning the government and empower its committees to become critical stakeholders in the law-making process. This will increase the stake that MPs have in the effective functioning of the institution, and disincentivise them from disrupting it. But this alone will not stop parliamentary disruptions.

The normalisation of disruption and the steamrolling of legislation in the monsoon session are warning signs that parliamentary functioning needs an urgent overhaul. If this pattern continues, the new Parliament building will be a modern and spacious venue for a dysfunctional institution.

Political disagreement on discussing issues such as the alleged Pegasus phone hacking and farm laws led to the washout of the session. There was only one exception. The ruling party and the Opposition reached a rare consensus on a constitutional amendment bill, which clarifies that states can maintain their list of socially and educationally backward classes. But the debate on the amendment was an aberration in the larger story of how Parliament passed laws during the session.

The two Houses went through the motions while passing 15 other laws. Amid continuing disruptions, Lok Sabha, on an average, took less than 10 minutes to pass a law, and Rajya Sabha passed each law in less than half an hour. The passage of these laws was more in form than in substance. In Lok Sabha, there were 13 bills in which no Member of Parliament (MP) spoke other than the minister in charge of the bill.

The political debate in the two Houses on a law is often in addition to a careful examination of the government’s legislative proposal by a parliamentary committee. And this aspect of legislative scrutiny continued to weaken in the monsoon session. The government introduced 11 bills in the session and pushed them through Parliament without scrutiny by standing committees. Only 12% of the government’s legal proposals have been sent to committees for scrutiny in the current Lok Sabha. This number was 27% in the 16th (2014-19), 71% in the 15th (2009-14) and 60% in the 14th (2004- 09) Lok Sabha.

Amid the slogan shouting and the raising of placards, the government accomplished almost all of its legislative agenda. The one significant piece of law that it did not bring before Parliament was an amendment to delicense electricity distribution. The government also brought in a law to end retrospective taxation and another one to increase private sector participation in public sector insurance companies.

A casualty of parliamentary disruption was the ability of the Opposition to hold the government accountable for its functioning. With Question House barely operational, ministers neither had to orally answer questions nor face pointed follow-ups on the work done by their ministries. MPs were able to get written answers from the government on various issues, including the handling of the Covid-19 situation, the vaccination drive, and deaths due to the pandemic. While Rajya Sabha was able to deliberate on the pandemic, in the Lok Sabha, no such discussion could occur due to disruptions.

Finally, this is the fourth consecutive session that has been cut short. The pandemic led to the curtailment of two sessions in 2020. This year, political parties agreed to end the budget session 11 days ahead of schedule to campaign in state elections. The monsoon session is yet another reminder that the institution needs to rethink how it deals with disruptions. It does not have any effective mechanism to reign in political parties for the conduct of their MPs. And since MPs disrupt Parliament on the instruction of their political parties, disciplining them hasn’t worked.

Parliament can change its rules to give MPs more teeth in questioning the government and empower its committees to become critical stakeholders in the law-making process. This will increase the stake that MPs have in the effective functioning of the institution, and disincentivise them from disrupting it. But this alone will not stop parliamentary disruptions.

The socialist leader and former minister, Madhu Dandavate, once remarked that a sense of accommodation by the treasury benches and a sense of responsibility by the Opposition benches is the balance essential for the smooth running of Parliament. And this balance can only be achieved by both sides working together to uphold the dignity of Parliament.

Chakshu Roy is the head of legislative and civic engagement, PRS Legislative Research

Follow Us

is licensed under a

Disclaimer: This data is being furnished to you for your information. PRS makes every effort to use reliable and comprehensive information, but PRS does not represent that this information is accurate or complete. PRS is an independent, not-for-profit group. This data has been collated without regard to the objectives or opinions of those who may receive it.

cricket exchangecrickex88.com
  • About Us
  • Careers
Copyright © 2025    crickexcasinos.com    All Rights Reserved.
cricket exchangecrickex88.com